Gov. Beshear needs to stop bullying school districts over COVID shutdowns


Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear announced on Monday that, because of lingering concerns about the COVID-19 pandemic, he was "recommending" all schools remain closed to in-person learning until September 28. According to former Kentucky School Boards Association spokesperson and education media watcher Brad Hughes, as of 10 p.m. Tuesday night, 48 of Kentucky's school districts had already announced they would comply with the Governor's "request."

Many parents, educators, and others have been shocked by this latest news given the massive efforts undertaken by districts to accommodate families who wanted in-person learning (with extremely complicated COVID precautions) and others who wanted a virtual option. They were also dismayed by the speed at which districts quickly agreed to the Governor's recommendation.

But in truth Governor Beshear was not making a recommendation at all. Superintendents had received the clear message from the Kentucky Department of Education that they better do as the Governor says - or else. In public webcast calls with Interim Commissioner Kevin Brown on Tuesday, August 4 and again on Tuesday, August 11 (watch starting around 15;20 for the next 8 minutes), Brown said that he and the Governor prided themselves on the fact that every single school district had bowed to previous requests to close to in person instruction.

If any district "chose" to open this time, they could expect a call from Commissioner Brown, the Kentucky Board of Education chair, the Governor, and state health officials who would try to change their minds - and perhaps the districts should have their attorneys there too. "My goal would be to have a different outcome at the end of the conversation and that would be a goal that would be achieveable," Brown said.

If districts continue to resist the recommendations, Brown said the Governor could issue executive orders to force their compliance, or public health officials could shut down their buildings or the KBE could issue an emergency regulation forcing them to do so. But it's all going to start with "a very intimate discussion if your district is one that decides to defy the recommendation." 

Kentucky educators decried former Governor Matt Bevin's "bullying" when he said mean things about their resistance to his ideas for pension reform. Where is the outcry when the Beshear administration tries to coerce districts into closing statewide, especially when many rural districts have had extremely few cases, and when data suggests (especially young) children are at low risk for getting or transmitting the virus?

Why is Commissioner Brown doing this at the behest of Beshear? Why has no member of the Kentucky Board of Education challenged these heavy-handed tactics on the part of the Commissioner? Is it because Governor Beshear fired board members the last time they took positions at odds with him and had new members fire the previous Commissioner, effectively destroying the independence of KBE, an illegal power grab that the state legislature refused to stop or repudiate? 

Why are superintendents and educators not screaming in protest over Beshear's disingenuous use of the word "recommendation" and his annhilation of local autonomy? Had former Governor Bevin or former Commissioner Wayne Lewis done these things superintendents would have lit up the media with their complaints and educators would have marched on Frankfort.

So what is different? Is it because educators used their considerable political influence to get Beshar elected? Is it because the Kentucky Education Association, which last week demanded a statewide closure of schools if test rates stay above 5 percent, donated over a million dollars to Beshear's election campaign?

Andy Beshear is the governor the education establishment wanted. And now he's proving himself even more of a "bully" than his predecessor when it comes to forcing his views on our schools and districts. 

But it's not too late for educators to stand up for the students they serve. As of today over 120 school districts are still waiting to decide how to respond to Beshear's "recommendation." Will any of them have the courage to tell him no and fight for their local communities and local autonomy?

Gary Houchens, is a former teacher, principal, and school district administrator now serving as Professor of Educational Administration in the School of Leadership and Professional Studies at Western Kentucky University. 


6 comments on this story | Please log in to comment by clicking here
Please log in or register to add your comment

I personally find that this Governor is caring and genuinely concerned about the children in this state. There are still many churches in this state that are not having in person services due to the high risk of this virus. Included in that number are many rural area churches where membership see's a large population of senior adults. It appeared to me that this is an article written by a Matt Bevin supporter who is still upset over last Novembers election. I would like to see less political motivation on this site. I see enough of that in social media and the news sites I read for daily scoops.

Wednesday, August 12, 2020
David Arvin

Well stated, Gary Houchens. Every newspaper in Kentucky ought to be running this piece.

Thursday, August 13, 2020

Bevin wanted teachers to be in the classroom working and benefiting kids. Beshear says stay home, let the kids and parents fend for themselves, while drawing full salary.

Remember when Bevin said kids would be harmed if they are not in school. Well now we see he was right, but no one deems that an important aspect.

Thursday, August 13, 2020

There is a 100-year pandemic that has had a devastating impact on the entire world! The disease is spreading in the US like wildfire! The number one priority of our leader is to protect the people. We know that schools that opened too early have already had to shut down again. Why? Because kids DO get sick, at least some of them do....but they ALL can carry the virus home with them. It’s true! Look it up! So if the governor opens schools and a child’s mother or grandmother gets sick and dies from the COVID that the child brought does the child feel then?

I, personally, would HATE to be in the governor’s position. No one wants kids to be out of school. No one. It is bad for kids, and bad for working parents. But how do you open schools if the doctors tell you it will make the virus spread...with more illness, more death, and a worse economy?

Do us all a favor......WEAR A MASk!!

Thursday, August 13, 2020
Bro Tim

Wonderfully stated! Each School Superintendent is charged with making the decisions for how to best educate the students in their care. There are ways to mitigate and protect our students and the most critical of which is to get them back into the classroom by all reasonable means necessary. Kentucky currently ranks 45th in the Nation for education, we cannot afford for our children suffer the "dumbing down" of education. Those who would sacrifice liberty for safety deserve neither. . . .Benjamin Franklin.

Sunday, August 16, 2020
Kathy Gornik

Gary Houchens is correct. It is up to local school administrators, school boards, teachers and parents to decide how and when they will open their schools. For perspective, while New Jersey and New York have 179 and 169 Covid deaths per 100,000 people respectively, Kentucky has 18.

We are not a state that has been devastated by the pandemic except for the actions taken by our governor to contain it. We are harming the lives and education of our children, who are minimally susceptible to the virus, through forced closures of schools. Such a decision needs to made by those closest to it who can best assess the risks and rewards.

Sunday, August 16, 2020

Powered by Creative Circle Media Solutions